I had grabbed a few paint samples the last time I was at Walmart. (Side note: I probably should have asked if they had any discontinued paint chips I could have, rather than just taking a few of each color. My kids ask for paint samples every. single. time. we got to Walmart, and they never seem to care, so I didn't think of it. But it's probably good to ask, and don't ever clean them out.)
(Okay, so they're peacocks, not turkeys. Close enough. You could add a red waggle to make them more turkey-like.)
Fan out the paint samples; glue the layers of samples together at the bottom.
Run a line of glue on the back of the paper tube. Glue it to your "feathers."
Add a beak and some google eyes, and you're done!